Short Reads

Court of The Hague confirms that the ACM can copy mobile phones during an inspection

Court of The Hague confirms that the ACM can copy mobile phones durin

Court of The Hague confirms that the ACM can copy mobile phones during an inspection

02.01.2018 NL law

On 22 November 2017, the District Court of The Hague dismissed a legal challenge that was brought against the Authority for Consumers and Markets (ACM) in preliminary relief proceedings.

In the course of an inspection, the ACM had made a copy of (virtually) all data on the business mobile phones of six employees who worked for the company subject to the inspection. The Court ruled that the ACM was permitted to do so.

The District Court first of all acknowledged that the amount of data stored on the six mobile phones combined was substantial. It was therefore not possible for the ACM to select the relevant business data at the premises of the company during the inspection, which meant the selection had to be made at a later date after the data had been copied. Although this meant that private data stored on the devices was also copied, the District Court did not consider this to be unlawful. The interests of the ACM investigation outweigh the right to privacy, provided there are sufficient guarantees to prevent the ACM from inspecting the data without being entitled to do so.

Such guarantees must conform with the principles set out in the Vinci-judgment of the European Court of Human Rights [see our May 2015 Newsletter]. This means that after the inspection, the person subject to the investigation must be given the opportunity to challenge in a concrete and effective manner the lawfulness of the seizure and must be able to request the return or destruction of the digital data.

The District Court then assessed whether the ACM's procedure for inspecting digital data - as set out in their manual (the "ACM Werkwijze voor onderzoek in digitale gegevens") - provides these guarantees. The first selection by the ACM takes place automatically as search terms are applied to the copied data. The ACM officials will not glance through non-selected data and to a certain extent the company can influence the search terms that are applied because it will receive a list of applied search terms and will be given the opportunity to react to this list. The company then receives a copy of the selected data and both the company and the owners of the mobile phones will be given the opportunity to indicate which data is private and thus wrongly selected. According to the ACM, they are not required to provide extensive reasons for their objection and if the ACM does not agree they can bring the issue before a court. The District Court therefore concluded that the ACM procedure provides sufficient guarantees.

In the judgment, the District Court ruled that the ACM's procedure for inspecting digital data provides sufficient guarantees to prevent the ACM from inspecting digital data to which it is not entitled. The ACM was therefore allowed to make a copy of (virtually) all data on the mobile phones and bring such a copy to its premises for further selection and inspection.

This article was published in the Competition Law Newsletter of January 2018. Other articles in this newsletter:

1. Court of Justice: Suppliers of luxury goods may prohibit their authorised distributors from selling on third party internet platform
2. Court of Justice dismisses appeal by Telefónica on non-compete clause in telecoms transaction

Team

Related news

14.10.2019 NL law
Kamerdebat over digitalisering van de overheid: aandacht voor bescherming burger vereist

Short Reads - Op 24 september 2019 zijn er vier moties in stemming gebracht én aangenomen door de Tweede Kamer. De moties hebben als gemeenschappelijke deler dat ze in het teken staan van de steeds groter wordende digitalisering bij de overheid. Het achterliggende doel van de moties is dat de burger voldoende beschermd moet worden tegen deze digitalisering.

Read more

03.10.2019 NL law
The ACM has to pay: moral damages awarded to real estate traders

Short Reads - The Dutch Authority for Consumers and Markets (ACM) needs to cough up a total of EUR 120,000 in moral damages to three real estate traders. The Dutch Trade and Industry Appeal Tribunal (CBb) agreed with the real estate traders that the annulment of the ACM's cartel decisions against them was insufficient compensation for the harm they suffered as a result of the length of the procedure and the press coverage of their cases.

Read more

03.10.2019 NL law
It's in the details: HSBC fine quashed for insufficient reasoning

Short Reads - The General Court annulled the EUR 33.6 million fine imposed on banking group HSBC for its participation in the euro interest rates derivatives cartel. Full annulment was granted based on the Commission's failure to provide sufficiently detailed reasoning for the first step of the fine calculation, establishing the value of sales. As the value of sales could not be established in a straightforward way, the Commission used a proxy. When doing so, the Commission needs to properly explain its reasoning to allow the companies fined to understand how it arrived at the proxy. 

Read more

03.10.2019 NL law
Margrethe Vestager to play matchmaker between enforcement and regulation

Short Reads - Current Competition Commissioner Margrethe Vestager may face even greater challenges in the next European Commission. President-elect Ursula von der Leyen has not only nominated Vestager for a second term as Commissioner for Competition, but has also asked her to coordinate the European Commission's digital agenda. As a result, Vestager may soon be tackling digital issues through competition enforcement whilst also proposing additional regulation to deal with these (and related) issues pre-emptively.

Read more

Our website uses functional cookies for the functioning of the website and analytic cookies that enable us to generate aggregated visitor data. We also use other cookies, such as third party tracking cookies - please indicate whether you agree to the use of these other cookies:

Privacy – en cookieverklaring