Articles

Digital Law Up(to)date: (1) the download of a software with a permanent licence can constitute a “sale of goods”; (2) alert of the BEUC regarding the privacy policy of WhatsApp and its new term of use

Digital Law Up(to)date: (1) the download of a software with a permane

Digital Law Up(to)date: (1) the download of a software with a permanent licence can constitute a “sale of goods”; (2) alert of the BEUC regarding the privacy policy of WhatsApp and its new term of use

24.09.2021 EU law

In this blog, we briefly present two interesting news in the field of digital law: (1) a judgment of the CJEU considering that the download of a software with a permanent licence can constitute a “sale of goods”, and (2) an alert of the BEUC regarding the privacy policy of WhatsApp and its new terms of use.

(1) Digital Law Up(to)date: The supply of a copy of software together with a licence to use it can constitute a "sale of goods”

The 16 September 2021 (C-410/19), the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) states that the supply by a company, in return for payment of a fee, of a computer software to a customer by electronic means where that supply is accompanied by the grant of a perpetual licence to use that software can be covered by the concept of ‘sale of goods’.

The case concerns the Directive 86/653 relating to self-employed commercial agents and the qualification of a “commercial agent”. According to article 1(2), three conditions must be met: a person must (1) be a self-employed intermediary, (2) be contractually bound to a principal, and (3) have an activity which may consist either simply in being an intermediary for the sale or purchase of goods or in both acting as intermediary and concluding sales or purchases of goods.

To reach its conclusion, the CJEU proceeds in two stages:

  1. A computer software can be classified as “goods”, irrespective of whether it is supplied on a tangible medium or (as in the present case) by electronic download;
  2. The making available of a copy of computer software by means of a download and the conclusion of a permanent user licence agreement for that copy, in return for payment of a fee, involve the transfer of the right of ownership of that copy, and thus a sale.

(2) Digital Law Up(to)date: WhatsApp in turmoil

During the summer, the European Consumer Organisation (BEUC) launched an external alert against WhatsApp to the European Commission and the Consumer Protection Cooperation Network (CPC). This alert is possible thanks to Regulation 2017/2394 on cooperation between national authorities responsible for the enforcement of consumer protection laws.

Specifically, WhatsApp is alleged to have pressured its users to accept its new terms of use and its privacy policy changes. BEUC also considers that these documents are not sufficiently transparent and clear. These alleged breaches are elaborated in a report entitled “What's up with WhatsApp? An assessment of WhatsApp's practices in the light of EU consumer protection rules”. Two main problems are highlighted: Whatsapp's aggressive practices (in the sense of the Unfair Commercial Practices Directive) and the opacity of the new policies (violating provisions of the Unfair Contract Terms Directive).

Since the launch of the external alert, WhatsApp has been fined €225 million by the Irish Data Protection Commissioner for, among other things, a lack of transparency regarding personal data (see the decision here), after the European Data Protection Board adopted a dispute resolution decision on the basis of Art. 65 GDPR (see the decision here). BEUC sees the Irish decision as an additional convincing element against Whatsapp (see here).

 

By Edouard Cruysmans and Erik Valgaeren

Team

Related news

28.07.2022 NL law
Purely commercial interest also a legitimate interest? Council of State leaves the question unanswered.

Short Reads - On 27 July 2022, the Council of State confirmed that the Dutch Data Protection Authority wrongly imposed a €575,000 fine on VoetbalTV. But the Council did not answer the question whether the AP rightly or wrongly believes that a purely commercial interest cannot be a legitimate interest within the meaning of the General Data Protection Regulation.

Read more

28.07.2022 NL law
Zuiver commercieel belang ook gerechtvaardigd belang: Raad van State laat zich er niet over uit

Short Reads - Op 27 juli 2022 heeft de Raad van State bevestigd dat de Autoriteit Persoonsgegevens onterecht een boete van € 575.000 aan VoetbalTV heeft opgelegd. De hoop bestond dat de Afdeling antwoord zou geven op de vraag of de AP terecht of onterecht meent dat een zuiver commercieel belang géén gerechtvaardigd belang kan zijn in de zin van de Algemene Verordening Gegevensbescherming. Het antwoord op deze vraag blijft echter uit.  

Read more