Short Reads

Contracts & Corona: force majeure and related topics

Contracts & Corona: force majeure and related topics

Contracts & Corona: force majeure and related topics

23.03.2020 BE law

The spread of the coronavirus may have some consequences that affect your ability to perform your obligations under your contracts, or your co-contractors’ ability to perform theirs. We provide some insight on a few pressing questions.

Does a debtor still have to honour its contract when this has become impossible, for instance due to government measures?

In order to be freed from performing its contract without being liable for damages, a debtor will have to prove force majeure. The question arises when one can rely on force majeure.

As a general rule of thumb, you should first check the contract for any provisions governing force majeure. These provisions could specify the rules of general contract law and may either restrict/exclude or extend the possibility to invoke force majeure. They may also give further guidance on what a debtor should do when it wants to invoke force majeure, and/or what the consequences will be.

If no contractual provision exists, the debtor will have to rely on the rules of general contract law and prove the following:

  1. It has become impossible (and not merely more onerous) for the debtor to perform the contract. Measures ordered by the Government that render it (legally – this is the so-called Fait du Prince – or practically) impossible to perform the obligations under the contract may amount to force majeure.

    However, mere negative advice given by the government to the public (such as negative travelling advice) may on the other hand not meet the high threshold of impossibility. Also, an obligation to pay money is in principle never impossible to perform.
     
  2. The force majeure event was unforeseeable at the time of the conclusion of the contract.
  3. The debtor could not reasonably avoid the force majeure event, nor was it the cause of this event.

It is evident that any of these requirements will have to be assessed on a case-by-case basis.

Force majeure will not exonerate a debtor if it was already in default before the event occurred and the creditor had put it on notice.

Please note that the above answers are based on the rules of general contract law and that in specific fields (e.g. travel contracts, air transport contracts, public procurement contracts etc.) specific rules may apply.

What happens if the impossibility caused by the force majeure event is temporary?

The debtor will be released temporarily from performing the contract until such performance has become possible again. In the meantime, the co-contractor may suspend the performance of its own obligations too.

However, if the parties can no longer usefully perform the contract when the impediment is lifted, e.g. because time was of the essence, the impossibility caused by the force majeure event must be deemed permanent (see next question).

What happens if the impossibility caused by the force majeure event is deemed permanent?

The force majeure event will definitively release both parties from performing their obligations. The agreement will automatically lapse (unless the contract can live on without the affected obligations).

For instance, as a service provider, you will not have to provide the service, but will, in principle, not be entitled to payment either. You will have to reimburse any advances you may have received to the extent that no services were rendered. However, under certain circumstances, other solutions may prevail. It should also be noted that specific rules apply regarding contracts transferring specific and ascertained property.

What steps should the debtor take when performing its contractual obligations has become impossible due to force majeure?

The debtor should notify its co-contractor (in writing) that force majeure precludes it from performing the contract, explain why it constitutes force majeure and indicate the ensuing consequences.

Moreover, the debtor must also take reasonable measures to mitigate the damage of its co-contractor.

Does a debtor still have to perform its obligations if such performance is not per se impossible, but merely (significantly) more onerous?

As pointed out above (see first question), the mere fact that obligations have become more onerous does not entitle a debtor to invoke force majeure under Belgian law. In some foreign jurisdictions, the opposite solution (known as the doctrine of hardship) is accepted, but hardship is not available under the Belgian rules of general contract law.

However, many contracts include hardship clauses.  In addition, if you can demonstrate that no reasonable person placed in the same circumstances would insist that a debtor performs certain obligations, a judge may rule that a co-contractor's insistence amounts to an abuse of right. The judge may then order it to act like a reasonable co-contractor.

A so-called “innocent" debtor (i.e. a debtor not responsible for its default) may always request a moderate grace period from the judge. It will never be automatically entitled to this, but the judge may freely decide on such a request and may be especially receptive to it in the current circumstances.

 

This article provides some general insights on different legal questions. These insights do not constitute legal advice and may not be relied upon as if they were legal advice. The outcome of any legal analysis will strongly depend both on the specific facts and circumstances of each case and on the particularities of the sector and legal relationship involved. Our legal experts in the various domains concerned are available to assist you with the analysis of your questions and provide specific advice tailored to your case and circumstances.

Team

Related news

03.04.2020 NL law
COVID-19 and the Financial Markets

Short Reads - As COVID-19 spreads across the globe, companies face various legal issues related to the disease and its spread. These issues result in disruption to business, alongside the related regulatory and contractual implications. The crisis is severely affecting financial institutions and financial markets too. Both the Dutch and European financial regulators are closely monitoring the situation given the continuing impact of the COVID-19 pandemic on the financial markets.

Read more

02.04.2020 NL law
Stibbe in Amsterdam answers questions from consumers, small business foundations and NGOs about the coronavirus

Inside Stibbe - In a special Q&A (in Dutch), lawyers from our Amsterdam office share their legal expertise and strive to provide answers to questions put to us by consumers, self-employed persons, enterprises large and small, foundations and NGOs as a result of the corona crisis.

Read more

03.04.2020 NL law
Volledig virtuele AVA of ledenvergadering wordt mogelijk; instellen van noodwet goedgekeurd door Ministerraad

Short Reads - Vandaag heeft de Ministerraad ingestemd met toezending naar de Raad van State van een noodwet. Deze noodwet zal het voor alle rechtspersonen mogelijk maken om een volledig virtuele algemene vergadering of ledenvergadering te houden. Nederland volgt daarmee andere Europese landen zoals Italië, Frankrijk, Duitsland en Luxemburg.

Read more

01.04.2020 BE law
Tijdelijke werkloosheid – Maatregelen aangaande telewerk, physical distancing in essentiële en niet-essentiële bedrijven – Sociale verkiezingen

Articles - Elisabeth Matthys en Dieter Demuynck bespreken tijdelijke werkloosheid ten tijde van de Covid-19 crisis. Daarnaast verklaren ze de maatregelen aangaande telewerk en physical distancing in essentiële en niet-essentiële bedrijven, en gaan ze dieper in op de impact van de crisis op de organisatie van de sociale verkiezingen.

Read more

This website uses cookies. Some of these cookies are essential for the technical functioning of our website and you cannot disable these cookies if you want to read our website. We also use functional cookies to ensure the website functions properly and analytical cookies to personalise content and to analyse our traffic. You can either accept or refuse these functional and analytical cookies.

Privacy – en cookieverklaring