Short Reads

It's in the details: HSBC fine quashed for insufficient reasoning

It's in the details: HSBC fine quashed for insufficient reasoning

It's in the details: HSBC fine quashed for insufficient reasoning

03.10.2019 NL law

The General Court annulled the EUR 33.6 million fine imposed on banking group HSBC for its participation in the euro interest rates derivatives cartel. Full annulment was granted based on the Commission's failure to provide sufficiently detailed reasoning for the first step of the fine calculation, establishing the value of sales. As the value of sales could not be established in a straightforward way, the Commission used a proxy. When doing so, the Commission needs to properly explain its reasoning to allow the companies fined to understand how it arrived at the proxy. 

It is therefore advisable for companies active in industries where sales values are difficult to determine, to always double-check the depth of reasoning behind the Commission's fine calculations.

In 2016, the Commission imposed fines on HSBC, JPMorgan and Crédit Agricole for taking part in a cartel aimed at distorting the pricing of Euro Interest Rate Derivatives (EIRDs). These are derivative financial products whose prices are linked to the Euro Interbank Offered Rate (Euribor). The Euribor is established as an average of the banks' submissions, including those of HSBC. The sanctioned behaviour consisted of exchanges of information concerning the EIRDs and manipulation of the Euribor. The General Court largely agreed with the Commission on the main substantive points. However, it still annulled the fine imposed on HSBC as a result of insufficient reasoning.

The Commission's Fine Guidelines take the companies' value of sales affected by the behaviour as a starting point to reach a fine amount which reflects the economic significance of the cartel. As the financial trading industry does not generate sales in the ordinary sense, the Commission considered cash receipts received under the EIRDs as the starting point. It then applied a reduction factor which was set at a very specific level: 98.849% without, according to the Court, explaining why the reduction factor was set at this level.

The Court found that precision in establishing the reduction factor is fundamental, with the smallest change having a great impact on the fine. Additionally, because the Commission chose to find a proxy for the value of sales, it was essential that HSBC had the chance to verify whether the proxy chosen was vitiated by any error. Therefore, due to the circumstances of the case, the Commission's motivation was insufficient.

Cartel cases in which the fine calculation involves establishing a proxy for the value of sales, put an additional burden on the Commission to properly explain its motivation. In such cases, companies should double-check whether the Commission's reasoning is sufficiently detailed to enable them to verify the fine calculations.

 

This article was published in the Competition Newsletter of October 2019. Other articles in this newsletter:

 

 

 

 

Team

Related news

09.01.2020 NL law
Deleting WhatsApp chats during dawn raids may cost you dearly

Short Reads - Companies should be aware that the Dutch competition authority (ACM) will not only examine electronic records and emails, but can also check WhatsApp messages during dawn raids. The ACM recently imposed a fine of EUR 1.84 million on a company for non-cooperation with a dawn raid; its highest fine so far for non-cooperation. Several of the company’s employees had left WhatsApp groups and deleted chats before handing over their mobile phones for inspection.

Read more

16.01.2020 NL law
De Amsterdamse milieuzone voor brom- en snorfietsen: voertuigen van een bepaald jaar weren is mogelijk bij ontbreken van een redelijk alternatief

Short Reads - ABRvS 20 november 2019, ECLI:NL:RVS:2019:3865 Deze blog is het vierde deel in een reeks Stibbeblogs over gemeentelijke milieuzones. In 2017 oordeelde de Afdeling over de milieuzone voor personen- en bestelauto’s met dieselmotoren in Utrecht. In 2018 presenteerde de staatssecretaris van Infrastructuur en Waterstaat haar beleid voor harmonisatie van uiteenlopende gemeentelijke milieuzones. Een jaar geleden maakten wij in een FAQ de balans op over de harmonisatie van milieuzones.

Read more

09.01.2020 NL law
Access to the file in Dutch competition procedures: too little too late?

Short Reads - Companies beware: the ACM’s and European Commission’s approach to access to the file are not aligned. According to an interim relief judge, the ACM cannot be forced to grant a company access to a broader set of documents in competition procedures. A potential error in the administrative procedure can be remedied before a court at a later stage. This is different to the right to access to the Commission’s file during administrative procedures, as acknowledged in EU case law.

Read more

10.01.2020 NL law
Is het mededingingsrecht de reddingsboei van zwakke zzp’ers?

Articles - Het toenemende aantal zzp'ers heeft ook mededingingsrechtelijke gevolgen. Volgens de ACM werkt de markt namelijk niet goed als zzp'ers door lage uurtarieven onder het bestaansminimum komen. Jan Truijens Martinez en Simone Evans bespreken in het Tijdschrift voor Arbeidsrecht in Context hoe eventuele belemmeringen die het mededingingsrecht opwerpt bij de bescherming van zzp'ers kunnen worden beperkt en of het mededingingsrecht eigenlijk wel het juiste instrument daarvoor is? 

Read more

09.01.2020 NL law
Competition rules and globalisation to face off in 2020

Short Reads - 2020 will likely revolve around the question whether competition rules should yield to globalisation and digitisation, with suggestions ranging from mere tweaks to competition rules to complementary regulation. Greater cooperation across data protection, consumer protection and competition law appears inevitable. Speedier solutions in more informal settings may become a reality, alongside more frequent use of behavioural remedies.

Read more

Our website uses functional cookies for the functioning of the website and analytic cookies that enable us to generate aggregated visitor data. We also use other cookies, such as third party tracking cookies - please indicate whether you agree to the use of these other cookies:

Privacy – en cookieverklaring