Short Reads

Abolishment of tax deductibility of coupon payments on AT-1 capital instruments announced per 1 January 2019

Abolishment of tax deductibility of coupon payments on AT-1 capital i

Abolishment of tax deductibility of coupon payments on AT-1 capital instruments announced per 1 January 2019

03.07.2018 NL law

On Friday 29 June 2018, the Dutch government made public its intention to abolish article 29a Dutch corporate income tax act ('DCITA'), per 1 January 2019. As a result of the abolishment of this provision, coupon payments on so-called additional-tier 1 ('AT-1') capital instruments made by banks and insurance companies will no longer be tax deductible. The amendment of the DCITA, which is aimed to be included in the tax package for 2019, will apply to coupon payments made after 1 January 2019, irrespective whether it concerns new or already existing AT-1 instruments.  

According to 29a DCITA, coupon payments on AT-1 instruments made by banks and insurance companies are currently deductible for DCITA purposes. The Dutch State Secretary of Finance, however, wants to abolish this rule per 1 January 2019 for various reasons. In the view of the State Secretary, the tax deductibility of AT-1 coupon payments provides for an incentive to attract AT-1 capital, instead of real equity (‘core capital’). Furthermore, the State Secretary puts forward that the government is aiming for a more equal treatment of equity and debt for tax purposes, which is achieved by making debt financing less attractive from a tax perspective. In a memorandum of February of this year, dealing with measures to counteract tax avoidance and evasion, this argument was also used by the State Secretary of Finance to substantiate why the earning stripping rules to be introduced per 1 January 2019 will not include a group escape rule (which is included in the ATAD directive). In the February 2018 memorandum, the argument is also used to introduce a generic thincap rule per 2020, which rule is expected to be especially relevant for banks and insurance companies. The announced thincap rule was already seen as a defacto by-passing of article 29a DCITA, because the thicap rules require a minimum equity percentage of 8. 

Another reason why article 29a DCITA will be abolished per 2019, is pressure from the European Commission ('EC'). Already back in 2015 the EC raised the question whether article 29a DCITA could constitute state aid. In another letter, dating from June 2018, the EC is asking The Netherlands to amend their regime to take away the state aid concern of the EC. In this letter, the EC also makes clear to have reviewed the tax treatment of AT-1 capital instruments in other Member States, and where necessary, Member States were asked by the EC to take action where needed from a state aid perspective. 

After the abolishment of article 29a DCITA, the question remains how to qualify (debt or equity), the AT-1 capital instruments when looking at the tax case law of the Dutch Supreme Court. According to the Dutch State Secretary, the AT-1 capital instruments would in that case qualify as equity, but whether this indeed is the case remains to be seen. When looking into this question, also the (possible) effects of the thin cap rule, which likely will be introduced per 2020 (see above), should be taken into consideration. 

Team

Related news

05.05.2021 NL law
The Dutch Scheme – tax aspects

Short Reads - On 1 January 2021, the Act on confirmation of private restructuring plans (Wet homologatie onderhands akkoord, also known as the “WHOA”, hereinafter: the “Dutch Scheme”) came into effect. We discussed several aspects of the Dutch Scheme in our previous blogs. In order to come to a successful scheme, it is important to consider tax aspects at an early stage of the restructuring process. This blog highlights the most important Dutch tax aspects of the Dutch Scheme.

Read more

01.04.2021 NL law
Public consultation on proposed amendment of Dutch classification rules for certain domestic and foreign legal entities

Short Reads - On 29 March 2021 the Dutch government has released a consultation document (the “Consultation Document”) containing a draft bill of law and explanatory memorandum to amend the Dutch classification rules for certain domestic and foreign legal entities.

Read more

09.03.2021 NL law
Consultation on ATAD 2 (reverse hybrids) and amendment arm’s-length principle in the Netherlands

Short Reads - As noted in our earlier Tax Alerts (see our Tax Alerts of March 2017 and July 2019), the EU Anti-Tax Avoidance Directive 2 ("ATAD 2") provides for minimum standards to neutralize hybrid mismatches and came into effect in the Netherlands as of 1 January 2020. However, as an exception, the rule that targets so-called “reverse-hybrid” mismatches will become effective only as of 1 January 2022.  

Read more