Short Reads

District Court The Hague: WhatsApp is more than data transition medium and must appoint Dutch representative

District Court The Hague: WhatsApp is more than data transition medium and must appoint Dutch representative

District Court The Hague: WhatsApp is more than data transition medium and must appoint Dutch representative

24.02.2017 NL law

On 22 July 2015, the Dutch Data Protection Authority ("DPA") imposed an order on WhatsApp Inc., backed by a penalty for non-compliance. The DPA concluded that WhatsApp must appoint a representative in the Netherlands within three months, subject to a penalty of €10,000 per day with a maximum of €1,000,000.

WhatsApp lodged an appeal against the DPA's decision and brought the case before the District Court of The Hague. A brief description of the relevant legal framework is presented below, followed by a discussion on WhatsApp’s most relevant arguments seeking the Court to dismiss the DPA's decision.

Under the Data Protection Directive (95/46/EC), which has been implemented in the Dutch Data Protection Act, a data controller that is established outside the EU and that uses equipment (automated or otherwise) situated in a Member State must designate a representative in that Member State unless such equipment is used for personal data transit only. Under the Dutch Data Protection Act, personal data may only be processed if the designated representative person or authority complies with the Dutch Data Protection Act. For the purposes thereof, the designated representative is regarded as the data controller.

WhatsApp alleged that Article 4 § 3 of the Dutch Data Protection Act (which states that a representative must be regarded as the controller) is inconsistent with the Data Protection Directive and therefore not binding. However, the District Court considers that the Directive does contain the obligation for a controller outside the EU to appoint a representative that can be held responsible by the supervisory authorities in the context of safeguarding rights and duties under the Data Protection Directive, which consideration is supported by Article 29 Working Party's advice on the applicable law of 16 December 2010. The Data Protection Directive must ensure the right to private life, even if the controller is not established within the EU. The rationale of the obligation is evidently that such protection of private life must not be hindered by the practical barrier of having to go to another country and turn to another legal system to safeguard privacy, as set out in the Data Protection Directive. The Court therefore dismisses WhatsApp's argument on this basis.

Furthermore, WhatsApp asserted that the absence of a local representative in the Netherlands should be allowed in anticipation of the GDPR. The GDPR comes in effect on 25 May 2018 and stipulates that a representative in a Member State of the EU should be appointed (instead of a representative in each Member State where equipment of a data controller outside the EU is situated). WhatsApp's argument in this respect also fails. The Court states that the GDPR does not apply yet and, moreover, WhatsApp did not provide any evidence showing that it had appointed a representative in another Member State.

WhatsApp also asserted that it cannot be regarded as a “controller” under the Dutch Data Protection Act because WhatsApp uses the automated equipment in the Netherlands for purposes of non-users’ personal data transit only. The District Court considered that users grant WhatsApp access to their telephone directory and, subsequently, WhatsApp compares the telephone numbers contained in its customers' directories with the telephone numbers on its own servers. The District Court therefore held that WhatsApp does not use its equipment in the Netherlands for data transit only.

WhatsApp finally argued that it is practically impossible to find a representative in the Netherlands because such representative would be held liable for any penalty for non-compliance with the Dutch Data Protection Act but would not have any influence on WhatsApp's activities. The District Court held that WhatsApp's statement that it is unable to find a representative is not a well-founded reason to discharge WhatsApp from its duty to appoint a representative in the EU Member State.

The District Court therefore upheld the DPA's decision. WhatsApp can still appeal against the District Court's decision by bringing the case before the Administrative Jurisdiction Division of the Council of State.

The case can be found here.

Team

Related news

02.04.2020 NL law
Stibbe in Amsterdam answers questions from consumers, small business foundations and NGOs about the coronavirus

Inside Stibbe - In a special Q&A (in Dutch), lawyers from our Amsterdam office share their legal expertise and strive to provide answers to questions put to us by consumers, self-employed persons, enterprises large and small, foundations and NGOs as a result of the corona crisis.

Read more

18.03.2020 EU law
Stibbe: COVID-19

Short Reads - In view of the developments concerning the coronavirus, we hereby inform you of our business operations and the measures we take to ensure the continuity of our services to you.

Read more

12.03.2020 EU law
Stibbe sets up corona team

Inside Stibbe - The coronavirus (COVID-19) may have legal consequences for your business. We have set up a team of specialists who can provide insight into the legal implications of the virus.

Read more

10.03.2020 NL law
De AVG staat niet in de weg aan de verwerking van persoonsgegevens door een toezichthouder tijdens een bedrijfsbezoek

Short Reads - Bedrijven die met toezicht worden geconfronteerd, zijn gehouden op verzoek van een toezichthouder in beginsel alle informatie te verstrekken. Met de komst van de Algemene verordening gegevensbescherming (AVG) is in de praktijk de vraag opgekomen of een toezichthouder bevoegd is om persoonsgegevens die onderdeel uitmaken van de gevraagde informatie te verwerken.

Read more

This website uses cookies. Some of these cookies are essential for the technical functioning of our website and you cannot disable these cookies if you want to read our website. We also use functional cookies to ensure the website functions properly and analytical cookies to personalise content and to analyse our traffic. You can either accept or refuse these functional and analytical cookies.

Privacy – en cookieverklaring