Short Reads

Dutch Supreme Court: the holder of a disclosed right of pledge over a receivable is entitled to file for bankruptcy of the debtor of such receivable

Dutch Supreme Court: the holder of a disclosed right of pledge over a receivable is entitled to file for bankruptcy of the debtor of such receivable

Dutch Supreme Court: the holder of a disclosed right of pledge over a receivable is entitled to file for bankruptcy of the debtor of such receivable

06.04.2017 NL law

In its judgment of 9 December 2016, the Supreme Court ruled that once the debtor of a receivable has been notified of a right of pledge over that receivable, the holder of the right of pledge not only has the power to collect the amount due under the receivable but also is entitled to file for the debtor's bankruptcy if the debtor fails to pay this amount.

Dutch Supreme Court 9 December 2016 (ECLI:NL:HR:2016:2833).

An investment company leased business space to a lessee. The lease receivables had been pledged to a third party, the pledgee. Following the investment company's failure to meet its payment obligations towards the pledgee, the pledgee notified the lessee of the right of pledge and demanded payment from the lessee of the lease receivables. When the lessee failed to pay, the pledgee filed for the lessee's bankruptcy.

The question that was put to the Supreme Court was whether the right to file for bankruptcy of the debtor of a pledged receivable remains with the pledgor or whether it is transferred to the pledgee upon notification of the right of pledge to the debtor. Unlike the District Court and the Court of Appeal, the Supreme Court ruled that the right to file for bankruptcy of the debtor of a claim which is subject to a disclosed right of pledge is transferred to the holder of such right of pledge. The Supreme Court reasoned that the right of a pledgee to collect the receivables pledged to it includes the right to take recourse on the assets of the debtor of those receivables and that this purpose is served by, amongst other things, filing for the debtor's bankruptcy. Given the close connection between the right to collect a receivable and the right to file for a debtor's bankruptcy, such right will transfer to the pledgee upon notification of the right of pledge to the debtor.

The judgment is broadly in line with existing case law. In 2015, the Supreme Court ruled that when a pledgee becomes entitled to collect receivables pledged to it, the pledgee may use all means of recovery that were previously available to the pledgor, including the enforcement of any security rights existing as security for those receivables. It also follows a well-established trend in the Supreme Court's case law to strengthen the rights of secured creditors (such as pledgees) by giving an extensive interpretation of such rights in enforcement scenarios.

As a result of this judgment, the pledgor of a disclosed right of pledge over a receivable does not have the right to file for bankruptcy of the debtor of that receivable without prior authorisation from the pledgee or alternatively a competent court. Thus, the position of the pledgor is weakened and the positioned of the pledgee is further strengthened.

Team

Related news

30.03.2022 LU law
(R)evolution of the securitisation framework

Articles - On 4 March 2022, the law of 25 February 2022 amending the law of 22 March 2004 on securitisation (the 2004 Law) has been published. It entered into force on 8 March 2022. This is a welcomed (r)evolution in the securitisation operations in the Grand Duchy of Luxembourg after 18 years of implementation of a tested and widely admitted legal framework.

Read more

25.02.2022
Stibbe Debt Finance Seminar/Webinar: issues you need to know about in 2022

Seminar - On Wednesday March 9 (16:00-17:30) Stibbe presents a seminar to update and outlook you on legal challenges facing financial market participants in 2022. In addition, on Wednesday March 16, 2022, (12:00-13:30), a webinar will also be held on the same theme. The in-person seminar will be held in Dutch and the online session in English.

Read more

11.03.2022 LU law
The New Luxembourg SFDR and Taxonomy Regulation Implementing Law

Articles - On 3 March 2022, the Luxembourg law of 25 February 2022 implementing a.o. the Sustainable Finance Disclosure Regulation (SFDR) and the Taxonomy Regulation has been published in the Official Journal of the Grand Duchy of Luxembourg. This law specifies the CSSF and CAA's supervisory and investigation powers concerning financial market participants and financial advisers under their supervision in relation to the control of the implementation of the SFDR and the Taxonomy Regulation, as well as, their administrative sanctioning powers in case of non-compliance by in-scope firms.

Read more