Short Reads

License wrongly rejected by the AFM

License wrongly rejected by the AFM

License wrongly rejected by the AFM

24.10.2016 NL law

In a recent decision, the Dutch appellate court in financial supervision matters ruled that the Netherlands Authority for the Financial Markets wrongfully rejected a license applied for by a Dutch investment firm. 

The firm offers binary options in the Netherlands. The Dutch regulator cannot reject a license because it considers the products the firm offers undesirable for a retail audience. The judgment confirms that also in case of firms offering high risk products, the powers of the regulators to refuse a licence are limited to the grounds laid down in the applicable laws and regulations. 

The judgment of the Trade and Industry Appeals Tribunal (College van Beroep voor het bedrijfsleven, the "CBb") of 4 October 2016 can be found here (in Dutch only) 

Background

Optieclub.nl B.V., a party that offers binary options, applied for a license to provide investment services in the Netherlands on 4 December 2012. Binary options are options with either a fixed payout amount or a payout amount of zero. The payout will occur when the underlying value (e.g. index, commodity, shares) moved towards the direction that is agreed upon in the option. The AFM and the Dutch Minister of Finance consider binary options as high risk products and aim for a ban on advertising for such products. The AFM even qualifies binary options as "toxic".

On 1 May 2014, the AFM rejected the license application. The AFM found that Optieclub did not comply with the requirement to maintain a sound operational management (integere bedrijfsvoering). On 16 January 2015, the District Court of Rotterdam ruled in favour of Optieclub. The AFM appealed.

The CBb judgment

The AFM found that Optieclub did not sufficiently take (i) measures to prevent itself or its employees to breach the Betting and Gambling Act (Wet op de kansspelen, the "WoK"), and/or (ii) measures to prevent Optieclub or its employees from performing acts that are contrary to generally accepted standards (maatschappelijke betamelijkheid) that can damage public confidence in Optieclub or the financial markets, since binary options – as a product – do not satisfy the requirement of safeguarding the interests of the firm´s customers.

The CBb ruled that the AFM is responsible for supervising the operation of the financial markets. The AFM has powers within this mandate to set requirements and use enforcement measures. The AFM, however, does not have powers to set requirements or use enforcement powers outside this mandate. In particular, the CBb ruled that the AFM does not have the mandate to use its powers with respect to breaches of the WoK. According to the CBb, establishing whether the WoK is breached is the task of the Netherlands Gaming Authority (Kansspelautoriteit). In this case, the Netherlands Gaming Authority did not establish that Optieclub breached the WoK. The CBb therefore ruled that as long as the breach of the WoK is not established, the AFM cannot claim that the activities of Optieclub damages the confidence in Optieclub or the financial markets.

In addition, the CBb ruled that the assessment whether Optieclub acts in breach of generally accepted standards relates to the actual market conduct of Optieclub or its employees and cannot be determined by reference to the product alone. The mere fact that Optieclub offers binary options does not justify the conclusion that Optieclub acts contrary to generally accepted standards that can damage the trust in Optieclub or the financial markets. 

Related news

31.03.2020 BE law
Will the COVID-19 pandemic have an impact on financial covenants?

Short Reads - In the Benelux and wider European market, many leveraged credit agreements still include certain financial covenants (including leverage covenants, interest and cashflow covers, etc.). All of these covenants rely (directly or indirectly) on the operational performance of a company (EBITDA). As it is expected that the coronavirus outbreak will negatively affect the operations of companies in a wide variety of sectors, any consequent breaches of financial covenants are likely inevitable.

Read more

08.04.2020 NL law
Hydrogen: Consultation by the Dutch regulator (ACM) on the role of group companies of TSOs and DSOs in the Dutch hydrogen market

Short Reads - On 30 March 2020, the Dutch Minister of Economic Affairs and Climate Policy (“Minister”) presented the ‘Government strategy on hydrogen’ (Kabinetsvisie Waterstof, also available in English), detailing the government strategy and policy agenda on hydrogen (further discussed in another Stibbe blog post).

Read more

18.03.2020 EU law
Stibbe: COVID-19

Short Reads - In view of the developments concerning the coronavirus, we hereby inform you of our business operations and the measures we take to ensure the continuity of our services to you.

Read more

03.04.2020 NL law
COVID-19 and the Financial Markets

Short Reads - As COVID-19 spreads across the globe, companies face various legal issues related to the disease and its spread. These issues result in disruption to business, alongside the related regulatory and contractual implications. The crisis is severely affecting financial institutions and financial markets too. Both the Dutch and European financial regulators are closely monitoring the situation given the continuing impact of the COVID-19 pandemic on the financial markets.

Read more

17.03.2020 NL law
Begunstigingstermijn en dwangsommen bij overmacht door crises

Short Reads - Als de begunstigingstermijn die aan een last onder dwangsom is verbonden voor een overtreder niet haalbaar is, kan het bestuursorgaan de last opheffen, opschorten of verminderen. De huidige crisissituatie in Nederland biedt bestuursorganen ruimte om de looptijd van handhavingsbesluiten op te schorten. In dit bericht zetten wij de mogelijkheden daartoe uiteen en schetsen wij de randvoorwaarden waaraan zo’n opschorting moet voldoen.

Read more

This website uses cookies. Some of these cookies are essential for the technical functioning of our website and you cannot disable these cookies if you want to read our website. We also use functional cookies to ensure the website functions properly and analytical cookies to personalise content and to analyse our traffic. You can either accept or refuse these functional and analytical cookies.

Privacy – en cookieverklaring