Short Reads

English Court enforces arbitral award including a contractual penalty

English Court enforces arbitral award including a contractual penalty

English Court enforces arbitral award including a contractual penalty

05.02.2016 EU law

The English High Court has enforced a Swiss-seated arbitral award (the Award) issued by the Court of Arbitration for Sport (CAS), notwithstanding that the Award ordered a payment representing enforcement of a contractual penalty.

The claimant entered into two contracts with an Italian football club regarding the sale of financial rights consisting of the "registration rights" of a football player. The contracts required payment by instalments. The second contract was governed by Swiss private law and provided for arbitration under the rules of the CAS. After the football club had failed to pay a sum due, the claimant launched arbitration proceedings. The CAS arbitration panel ordered that the football club pay a sum which included the payments due and an additional Penalty Sum on the basis of a provision of Swiss law, providing that a judge should reduce a contractual penalty which is considered excessive. On appeal by the club, the Award was upheld by the Swiss court. The claimant subsequently sought to enforce the Award in England.

Punishing clauses are not enforceable under English law. The Court did however not consider that the Award of the penalty was contrary to public policy regulation for the purposes of Article V(II) of the New York Convention 1958. The Court concluded that the prohibition of the enforcement of penalty clauses does not protect a "universal principle of morality" and the penalty clause was not "injurious to the public good" to the extent that enforcement thereof should automatically be refused.  On this basis, the governing law as applied by the CAS arbitration panel was considered by the Court. The parties had chosen Swiss law as the law governing the contract and the CAS had exercised its power to reduce the penalty, so that this reduction was found compliant with Swiss law.

The decision is groundbreaking in the context of international transactions, in which the parties may choose a governing law of a particular jurisdiction to govern their contractual obligations, in casu Swiss law, but may look to another jurisdiction for enforcement.  It is particularly important given that penalty clauses are a relatively regular feature in transactions in many sectors and jurisdictions. 

 

Team

Related news

05.09.2018 NL law
Consultation on additional remuneration restrictions within the financial sector

Short Reads - A team from Stibbe has participated in the public consultation launched by the Minister of Finance on additional remuneration restrictions within the financial sector. In their response (in Dutch), the Stibbe team pointed out that there are several legal objections to the proposed measures. Furthermore, the team has raised questions regarding the necessity and legal justification for introducing these additional measures.

Read more

28.08.2018 NL law
Het aanleidingsvereiste: hetzelfde werk voor dezelfde klanten is onvoldoende voor opvolgend werkgeverschap

Articles - De werknemer betoogde in deze zaak dat sprake was van opvolgend werkgeverschap omdat hij zowel bij TSN als bij Tzorg jarenlang – drie jaar Tzorg, twee jaar TSN en weer twee jaar Tzorg – exact dezelfde werkzaamheden had verricht (het verlenen van dezelfde zorg aan dezelfde cliënten). De kantonrechter maakte daar korte metten mee: dit door de werknemer gehanteerde criterium is te breed en zou tot zeer ongerijmde uitkomsten kunnen leiden.

Read more

25.07.2018 NL law
Rechter niet verplicht tot ambtshalve toepassing van artikel 1:125 lid 2 Wft (annotatie)

Articles - De Wbfo maximeert de vertrekvergoeding van bestuurders en andere dagelijks beleidsbepalers op een vast jaarsalaris (artikel 1:125 lid 2 Wft) en beoogt volgens de parlementaire geschiedenis fundamentele maatschappelijke belangen te beschermen: het tegengaan van excessieve beloningen en het beschermen van de consument, samenleving en de financiële stabiliteit.

Read more

Our website uses cookies: third party analytics cookies to best adapt our website to your needs & cookies to enable social media functionalities. For more information on the use of cookies, please check our Privacy and Cookie Policy. Please note that you can change your cookie opt-ins at any time via your browser settings.

Privacy – en cookieverklaring