Articles

Dutch Supreme Court reconsiders its 1989 Vis q.q./NMB Judgment: all money transfers credited to a payee's bank account after bankruptcy of the payor must be reimbursed to the payor's bankrupt estate

Dutch Supreme Court reconsiders its 1989 Vis q.q./NMB Judgment: all money transfers credited to a payee's bank account after bankruptcy of the payor must be reimbursed to the payor's bankrupt estate

Dutch Supreme Court reconsiders its 1989 Vis q.q./NMB Judgment: all money transfers credited to a payee's bank account after bankruptcy of the payor must be reimbursed to the payor's bankrupt estate

30.04.2015 NL law

In a judgment dated 20 March 2015, the Dutch Supreme Court ruled that all banks and intermediaries involved in the execution of a bank transfer, including the bank responsible for recording receipt of the bank transfer into the account held with it by the payee, qualify as parties whose services are directly or indirectly used by the payor in connection with the bank transfer. 

Therefore, according to the Dutch Supreme Court, all bank transfers initiated before, but credited to a payee's bank account after, bankruptcy of the payor are now eligible for reimbursement to the payor's bankrupt estate upon demand by the bankruptcy administrator.

Dutch Supreme Court 20 March 2015 (ECLI:NL:HR:2015:689)

One of the general principles of Dutch bankruptcy law is that a bankrupt debtor can no longer dispose of any assets belonging to his bankrupt estate from the date bankruptcy is declared. In its 1989 Vis q.q./NMB judgment, the Dutch Supreme Court ruled that a bank transfer received by a creditor of a bankrupt debtor must be reimbursed to the bankrupt estate if, on the day of bankruptcy, the bank processing that bank transfer on behalf of the bankrupt debtor (the "Payor's Bank") had not yet completed all necessary actions in order to effect the bank transfer. The actions to be carried out by the Payor's Bank generally include (i) debiting the account held by the payor and, if the bank account of the payee is held with another Dutch bank (the "Payee's Bank"), (ii) debiting the account held by the Payor's Bank with the Dutch Central Bank, and (iii) instructing the Dutch Central Bank to credit the account held by the Payee's Bank with the Dutch Central Bank. In order to complete the bank transfer, the Payee's Bank must credit the bank account held with it by the payee. Pursuant to the 1989 Vis q.q./NMB judgment, a bank transfer received by a payee after a payor's bankruptcy was deemed final if the Payor's Bank had completed the actions to be taken by it prior to the date of bankruptcy, irrespective of whether the Payee's Bank had credited the bank account held with it by the payee.

In its recent judgment, the Dutch Supreme Court held that all banks and intermediaries involved in the execution of a bank transfer, including the Payee's Bank, qualify as parties whose services are directly or indirectly used by the payor in connection with the bank transfer. Therefore, according to the Dutch Supreme Court, all bank transfers credited to a payee's bank account on or after the day of bankruptcy of the payor are now eligible for reimbursement to the payor's bankrupt estate upon demand by the bankruptcy administrator.

The Dutch Supreme Court creates a simple (and bankruptcy administrator-friendly) new rule to assess whether or not a bank transfer made by a bankrupt payor must be reimbursed to the bankrupt estate: if the bank transfer is initiated before, but credited to the payee's bank account on or after the day of bankruptcy, the bankruptcy administrator can demand that the bank transfer is reversed. The Supreme Court stated in its decision that the new rule does not apply to bankruptcies declared prior to 20 March 2015.

 

Related news

15.11.2019 NL law
Het kerstmenu van de AFM: vijf gangen - Column Fondsnieuws

Short Reads - Vliegen de pepernoten, adventskalenders en kerstkransjes u alweer om de oren?  Nee, het aanmeten van een gezonde levensstijl wordt u aan het einde van het jaar niet makkelijk gemaakt. Gelukkig helpt het Voedingscentrum ons daar een handje bij; en wel met de 'Schijf van Vijf'. De AFM introduceerde vorig jaar iets vergelijkbaars voor de financiële sector.

Read more

07.11.2019 NL law
Banking & Finance 2019 Second Edition – The Netherlands and Luxembourg chapter

Articles - Maarten de Bruin, Rein van Helden, Rogier Raas and Robert Steeg have all contributed to the Chambers and Partners Banking & Finance 2019 Second Edition, providing the Netherlands chapter. The Luxembourg chapter was written by Gérald Origer, Jean-Marc Delcour, Steven Paridaens and Nicolas Pradel.

Read more

13.11.2019 NL law
A new Act on the Supervision of Trust Offices

Articles - Roderik Vrolijk and Soeradj Ramsanjhal published an article in the Dutch Financial Law Review as a follow-up on their article two years ago in the same journal. The authors specifically shed light on the customer due diligence and open norms of the new Act on the Supervision of Trust Offices 2018, that entered into force on 1 January 2019. 

Read more

31.10.2019 NL law
EBA Publishes Follow-Up Report on 2018 FinTech Roadmap

Short Reads - Building on its 2018 FinTech Roadmap, the EBA has issued a report focused on potential impediments to the cross-border provision of banking and payment services. In the 29 October 2019 report, the EBA identifies three regulatory areas in which the further integration of European banking and payment services markets can be improved.  The three areas the EBA addresses are authorisation and licensing, conduct of business and consumer protection requirements, and anti-money laundering ("AML") and countering the financing of terrorism ("CFT").

Read more

08.11.2019 BE law
Interview with Wouter Ghijsels on Next Gen lawyers

Articles - Stibbe’s managing partner Wouter Ghijsels shares his insights on the next generation of lawyers and the future of the legal profession at the occasion of the Leaders Meeting Paris where Belgian business leaders, politicians and inspiring people from the cultural and academic world will discuss this year's central theme "The Next Gen".

Read more

Our website uses functional cookies for the functioning of the website and analytic cookies that enable us to generate aggregated visitor data. We also use other cookies, such as third party tracking cookies - please indicate whether you agree to the use of these other cookies:

Privacy – en cookieverklaring