Articles

Digital Law Up(to)date: be aware of your Facebook wall… you could be liable for comments posted by others

Digital Law Up(to)date: be aware of your Facebook wall… you could be

Digital Law Up(to)date: be aware of your Facebook wall… you could be liable for comments posted by others

14.09.2021 EU law

In this blog, we briefly present a recent judgment of the European Court of Human Rights on the liability for content posted by a third party on a Facebook wall.

In the Sanchez v. France judgment of 2 September 2021 (available only in French), the European Court of Human Rights (ECtHR) upheld the criminal conviction of the manager of a public Facebook wall (the applicant) for failing to react to racist comments posted by a third party in an electoral context.

According to the ECtHR, the conviction is an interference provided for by law and pursuing a legitimate aim (the protection of the rights of others). The Court then analyses proportionality by using the criteria developed in its case of Delfi AS v. Estonia (also used in a case of Jezior v. Poland). Three points of attention:

  • First, recalling that Article 10 protects information or ideas that offend, shock or disturb, the ECtHR states that this protection is not absolute. In casu, the posts were clearly unlawful.
  • Secondly, the electoral context. Altough the ECtHR does not usually tolerate restrictions on freedom of expression in case of political speech, it states that using of this freedom in this context must respect another democratic foundation: the equal dignity of all human beings. As the electoral speech is often stereotyped and without nuance, the ECtHR stresses that the impact of racist speech in such context can be more damaging.
  • Finally, the measures taken by the applicant, i.e. the removal of the public nature of the Facebook wall and the publication of a message asking third parties to monitor the content of their post, were not sufficient.

 

The ECtHR concludes that the criminal conviction of the applicant did not violate his freedom of expression.

 

By Edouard Cruysmans and Erik Valgaeren

Team

Related news

24.09.2021 EU law
Digital Law Up(to)date: (1) the download of a software with a permanent licence can constitute a “sale of goods”; (2) alert of the BEUC regarding the privacy policy of WhatsApp and its new term of use

Articles - In this blog, we briefly present two interesting news in the field of digital law: (1) a judgment of the CJEU considering that the download of a software with a permanent licence can constitute a “sale of goods”, and (2) an alert of the BEUC regarding the privacy policy of WhatsApp and its new terms of use.

Read more

26.08.2021 BE law
Sarah De Wulf and Malik Baba co-authored a book dedicated to the legal aspects of the video-game industry

Articles - The book, entitled 'Legal Aspects of the video-game industry', provides a first answer to the most important legal questions that might arise in the lifecycle of a video-game company. These insights are intended to be applicable irrespective of jurisdictions, illustrated by real-life situations and easy to read for individuals without a legal background.

Read more

13.09.2021 NL law
Adopting the new Standard Contractual Clauses to secure international personal data transfers

Short Reads - Recently, the European Commission issued an implementing decision on standard new contractual clauses (“SCCs”) for the transfer of personal data to countries outside the European Economic Area. Organisations need to use the new SCCs from 27 September 2021 and onwards. Transitional periods apply for existing international data transfer agreements. To meet their obligations under the General Data Protection Regulation, organisations need to make the appropriate changes in time.

Read more

26.08.2021 EU law
Facebook/Belgian DPA: Landmark ruling on cross-border enforcement under the GDPR

Short Reads - On 15 June 2021, the CJEU delivered an important judgment on the one-stop-shop mechanism. While the CJEU reinforced that the lead supervisory authority is the sole interlocutor in cross-border processing operations, it also contributed to the effective enforcement of the GDPR by reiterating the conditions under which supervisory authorities other than the lead supervisory authority can bring enforcement actions against such processing operations.

Read more

09.09.2021 BE law
Digital Law Up(to)date: (1) Parliamentary initiatives about cyber attacks; (2) ‘Zero tariff’ options before the CJEU; and (3) Council of State, GDPR and encryption

Articles - In this blog, we briefly present three interesting news in the field of digital law: (1) Parliamentary initiatives to tackle cyber attacks (2) "Zero tariff" options and open internet access do not mix! (3) Council of State, GDPR and encryption: validation of a decision of the Flemish Authorities

Read more