Short Reads

New competition tool: something old, something new, something borrowed

New competition tool: something old, something new, something borrowed

New competition tool: something old, something new, something borrowed

02.07.2020 NL law

Large online platforms may face more regulatory obligations, whilst non-dominant companies’ unilateral conduct may soon be curbed. The European Commission intends to tool up its kit by adding a new regulation to keep digital gatekeepers in check, as well as providing more clarity on how to define digital markets in its new Market Definition Notice.

It is also eyeing a market investigations tool, similar to that available to competition authorities in the UK and Greece. Consultations to collect stakeholders’ views on these initiatives are ongoing. Meanwhile, it is business as usual under the ‘old’ competition rules, with recently launched antitrust investigations into Apple’s conduct and possibly more frequent use of interim measures and restorative remedies.

Companies should be aware that more rules may be on the way: it is time to take stock of the potential implications for their businesses and respond accordingly to the ongoing consultations.

Something new: ex ante regulation of digital gatekeepers

Businesses are increasingly dependent on a limited number of large online platforms to connect them to consumers. These ‘gatekeeper’ platforms can use the large amounts of data gained from these connections to nip competition in the bud, for example by refusing competitors access to this data or by developing new activities in adjacent markets. Through the current consultation, the Commission intends to find ways to safeguard a fair trading environment and intensify the innovation potential and capacity across online platform ecosystems.

The suggested policy options range from revising the Platform-to-Business Regulation to include prescriptive rules on certain practices (such as ‘self-preferencing’, data access policies and unfair contractual provisions) to the introduction of a new ex ante regulatory framework for ‘gatekeeper’ online platforms, featuring blacklisted trading practices and tailor-made remedies (such as data access obligations or data portability requirements). Criteria based on significant network effects, size of user base, and ability to leverage data across markets may be used to distinguish ‘gatekeeper’ online platforms from others.

The recently launched consultation on the Market Definition Notice could also help to provide more guidance to companies on how to define product markets and geographic market, in light of increasing digitalisation.

Something borrowed: new competition tool

In parallel with the possible platform-specific ex ante regulation of digital gatekeepers, the Commission is considering a new competition tool resembling the market investigations tool available to competition authorities in the UK and Greece. In contrast to the Commission’s current power to conduct sector inquiries, this tool would allow the Commission to impose structural and behavioural remedies outside the scope of individual infringement proceedings, including the possibility of breaking up companies.

The tool aims to remedy structural market failures and prevent the creation of gatekeepers in digital and non-digital markets, without any prior finding of an infringement. The tool could either apply across all sectors or be sector-specific. Suggested options range from a dominance-based competition tool to a market structure-based tool to catch monopolising conduct by powerful non-dominant companies or tacit collusion in concentrated markets.

Something old: antitrust investigations

Irrespective of the consultations’ outcome, the Commission continues to tackle potential anti-competitive conduct under the ‘old’ competition rules. It recently launched an investigation into Apple’s App Store rules following complaints by Spotify and an e-book/audiobook distributor regarding Apple’s potential gatekeeper role. A similar investigation is ongoing at the Dutch Authority for Consumers and Markets (see our May 2019 newsletter).

In addition, the Commission is also looking into Apple’s conduct relating to Apple Pay. The Commission has concerns about Apple's terms, conditions, and other measures related to the integration of Apple Pay for the purchase of goods and services on merchant apps and websites on iOS/iPadOS devices, as well as alleged access restrictions to Apple Pay for specific products of rivals.

Prepare, beware, react

Companies should be aware of the potential implications of the current consultations (such as more rules to abide by), and give their reactions to the consultations before preparing for possible upcoming rules. The feedback period for both consultations ends on 8 September 2020. Based on the input received, the Commission intends to publish a proposal for implementing its plans by the end of this year.

 

This article was published in the Competition Newsletter of July 2020. Other articles in this newsletter:

Team

Related news

22.07.2021 NL law
Towards a European legal framework for the development and use of Artificial Intelligence

Short Reads - Back in 2014, Stephen Hawking said, “The development of full artificial intelligence could spell the end of the human race.” Although the use of artificial intelligence is nothing new and dates back to Alan Turing (the godfather of computational theory), prominent researchers – along with Stephen Hawking – have expressed their concerns about the unregulated use of AI systems and their impact on society as we know it.

Read more

08.06.2021 NL law
Actualiteiten milieustrafrecht: zorgelijke ontwikkelingen

Short Reads - Vrijdag 28 mei jl. hadden wij een inspirerend webinar over actualiteiten op het gebied van milieustrafrecht. Wij spraken gedurende 90 minuten onder meer over aansprakelijkheden van bestuurders, de zorgplichten, incidentenrapportages vanuit strafrechtelijk- en bestuursrechtelijk perspectief.

Read more

03.06.2021 NL law
First material judgment in Dutch damages proceedings in trucks infringement

Short Reads - In its judgment of 12 May 2021, the Amsterdam District Court ruled that it has not been established that it is definitively excluded that the trucks infringement led to damage to the claimants. However, this does not alter the fact that it must still be assessed for each claimant whether the threshold for referral to the damages assessment procedure has been met. For this to be the case, it must be plausible that a claimant may have suffered damage as a result of the unlawful actions of the truck manufacturers. The Amsterdam District Court has not yet ruled on this issue.

Read more

08.06.2021 NL law
De Europese Klimaatwet uitgelicht

Short Reads - Op 21 april 2021 is een voorlopig akkoord bereikt over de Europese Klimaatwet. Deze Klimaatwet kan worden gezien als de kern van de Europese Green Deal, die in december 2019 werd gepubliceerd door de Europese Commissie. Het overstijgende doel van deze instrumenten is om een klimaatneutraal Europa te bewerkstelligen in 2050. De Europese Klimaatwet zorgt ervoor dat deze klimaatneutraliteitsdoelstelling in een Europese verordening wordt vastgelegd. Dit blogbericht gaat nader in op de Europese Klimaatwet en legt uit wat dit met zich brengt.

Read more