Articles

Ambtshalve toetsing van Unierecht door de appelrechter

Ambtshalve toetsing van Unierecht door de appelrechter

Ambtshalve toetsing van Unierecht door de appelrechter

22.07.2016 NL law

Ambtshalve toepassing van de Richtlijn oneerlijke handelsbedingen (in appel). Verduidelijking van het arrest Heesakkers/Voets (2013). Indien de rechter op grond van Unierecht verplicht is om contractuele bedingen te toetsen aan de Richtlijn oneerlijke handelsbedingen, is hij gehouden dat ambtshalve te doen, dus ook indien partijen daarop geen beroep doen (arrest Heesakkers/Voets).

Deze verplichting geldt zowel in eerste aanleg als in appel. De appelrechter moet daarbij zo nodig buiten de grieven en het door de grieven ontsloten gebied treden, maar dient de rechtsstrijd van partijen in appel te respecteren. Een toe- of afwijzing van een vordering in eerste aanleg waartegen in appel niet is opgekomen, hoeft door de appelrechter niet te worden heroverwogen omdat hij vanwege de devolutieve werking van het appel niet bevoegd is over die vordering een oordeel te geven.

Attachment

Source: JBPr 2016/36, juni 2016

Related news

24.09.2020 BE law
Stibbe hosts a webinar on dawn raids organised by IBJ/IJE

Seminar - On 24 September 2020, several Stibbe lawyers ​​​​​explain the rights and obligations of companies when confronted with announced or unannounced raids. What do to when, for example, tax authorities, the competition authorities, police services or a bailiff are at your doorstep?

Read more

03.09.2020 NL law
COVID-19 impacts level and payment of antitrust fines

Short Reads - As well as granting companies leeway on certain COVID-19 initiated collaborations (see our May 2020 newsletter), the coronavirus outbreak has also led competition authorities to take a more lenient stance towards fine calculations and payments. The European Commission has extended the due date for fine payments by an additional three months in response to potential short-term liquidity issues brought about by the pandemic. Similar reasons led the Dutch Trade and Industry Appeal Tribunal to reduce a EUR 1 million cartel fine to just EUR 10,000.

Read more

03.09.2020 NL law
The ACM’s Green Deal: achieving sustainability via competition law?

Short Reads - The ACM has issued draft guidelines on the application of competition law to sustainability agreements. Companies entering into agreements that restrict competition but contribute to governmental sustainability objectives – i.e. lower CO2 emissions – may expect more room for collaboration. The proposed framework would allow these types of agreements if their anti-competitive effects are outweighed by their environmental benefits to society as a whole (rather than to in-market consumers only, as under the existing framework).

Read more

03.09.2020 NL law
Home, but not alone: Commission may complete dawn raids from home

Short Reads - The European Court of Justice (ECJ) has rejected Nexans’ appeal in the power cables cartel case. The Commission started the dawn raid at Nexans’ premises, but due to lack of time finished the raid at the Commission’s premises in Brussels. The ECJ found that the Commission can copy data and assess its relevance to the investigation at its own premises, while safeguarding companies’ rights of defence.

Read more