Short Reads

Update Sustainable Finance Disclosure Regulation

Update Sustainable Finance Disclosure Regulation

Update Sustainable Finance Disclosure Regulation

18.12.2020 NL law

AFM and AMF position paper on a European Regulation for the provision of ESG data, ratings, and related services.

On 15 December 2020, the Dutch Authority for the Financial Markets (‘AFM’) and the French Financial Markets Authority (‘AMF’) published a position paper in which they call for a European regulatory framework on the provision of ESG data, ratings, and related services. The key point the AFM and AMF argue is that providers of sustainability data and related services must be regulated to prevent misallocation of investments, greenwashing, and ensuring investor protection.

The aim of the position paper is to contribute to the current debate on the transparency, accuracy and reliability on ESG data, ratings, and related services offered by Sustainability-related service providers (‘SSPs’) to financial market participants.

This paper covers three questions.

What is the role of sustainability-related data, analysis and services in the financial system?

ESG data play an important role in matching supply and demand for sustainable investment. Investors and asset managers looking for sustainable investments need reliable ESG data and ESG-related services to support the shift towards greener economies. Furthermore, ESG data is relevant, in order to allow for the integration of sustainability risks and opportunities in the decision making process, to disclose such risks where relevant, and to properly assess the long-term values of their (potential) investments. FMPs need this data to comply with the European regulatory framework on sustainable finance, including the SFDR and the Taxonomy Regulation.

Why do we need to regulate providers of ESG data and services?

SSPs remain largely unregulated. A variety of measurement methods are used to generate sustainable data and assessments. There is a lack of transparency on these methodologies, which leads to risks of misallocation and missed opportunities. There is risk of mismatches between the expectations of the investor and actual ESG performance of the investment. Moreover, sustainability data is not always consistent, comparable and reliable.

What should this regulation look like?

Taking in consideration the mentioned considerations, the AFM and the AMF propose an ad hoc European mandatory regulatory framework for SSPs. Within this framework, providers that wish to provide services to European companies should be subject to authorisation and supervision by ESMA, and should be required to operate through an establishment located in the European Union. The regulatory focus will be on transparency about methodologies, potential conflicts of interest, and governance and internal control requirements. AFM and AMF advocate for a step by step approach: a set of core requirements for SSPs that serves as a starting point, to be reviewed periodically taking into account market developments and, where appropriate, complemented by additional measures. The scope of the regulation should be well-calibrated to take into account the innovation and the diversity of products offered.


Related news

15.10.2021 NL law
BRRD II implementation in the Netherlands

Short Reads - Recently, the Dutch bill for the implementation of BRRD II (i.e. Directive (EU) 2014/59 establishing a framework for the recovery and resolution of credit institutions and investment firms, as amended by Directive (EU) 2019/879) in the Netherlands was submitted to Dutch Parliament, where it is currently under debate.

Read more

01.10.2021 NL law
Vanaf 1 oktober strengere regelgeving voor verkoop van turbo’s aan particuliere beleggers

Short Reads - Turbobeleggers nemen veel risico’s en verliezen gemiddeld veel geld. De AFM vindt dat particuliere beleggers onvoldoende beschermd worden tegen de risico’s van turbo’s. De verkoop van turbo’s aan deze beleggers wordt daarom aan banden gelegd. Met ingang van 1 oktober geldt een hefboombeperking, een verplichte risicowaarschuwing en een verbod op handelsbonussen. Daarmee wil de Autoriteit Financiële Markten (AFM) particuliere beleggers beter beschermen tegen de risico’s van turbo’s.

Read more

14.10.2021 NL law
NFTs: New legal challenges on the horizon

Short Reads - Non-Fungible Tokens, widely known as NFTs, have recently gained much attention due to their role in the transfer of digital artworks. The market for NFTs grew from USD 13.5m in the first six months of 2020 to USD 2.5bn in the first half of 2021 and is still growing at an expansive rate. Notwithstanding their increasing popularity in the world of art, NFTs have many potential applications. In this blog Maciek Bednarski, Annemijn Witkam and Roderik Vrolijk explain what NFTs are and describe some of the legal challenges they will bring about.

Read more

20.09.2021 NL law
AFM: Beleggingsfondsen kunnen beleggers beter informeren over duurzaamheid

Articles - Beleggingsfondsen kunnen beleggers beter informeren over duurzaamheid. De informatieverschaffing van fondsen over duurzaamheidsrisico’s en duurzaamheidskenmerken is nog vaak te algemeen, daardoor krijgen beleggers te weinig inzicht in waar ze in investeren. Dat is een van de conclusies van de Autoriteit Financiële Markten (AFM) in een verkennend onderzoek naar de toepassing van de Sustainable Finance Disclosure Regulation (SFDR).

Read more

11.10.2021 NL law
Vervolgonderzoek van de AFM naar incidentmeldingen door asset managers

Articles - Sinds de uitbraak van het coronavirus wordt ook in de financiële sector meer op afstand samengewerkt. Dat brengt specifieke risico’s met zich mee. De Autoriteit Financiële Markten (AFM) gaat daarom vervolgonderzoek doen naar het melden van incidenten door asset managers. De reden is het uitblijven van een stijging van het aantal incidentmeldingen ondanks herhaalde oproepen daartoe.

Read more