Articles

Enable “likes” and bear joint-controllership

Enable “likes” and bear joint-controllership

Enable “likes” and bear joint-controllership

19.08.2019 EU law

The Court of Justice of the European Union recently ruled, in Case C-40/14 Fashion ID GmbH & Co. KG v Verbraucherzentrale NRW eV,  that a website operator that features “Like” social-media plugin from Facebook likely qualifies as joint-controller with Facebook for its website visitors’ personal data collection and transmission to Facebook.

The Court of Justice of the European Union recently ruled, in Case C-40/14 Fashion ID GmbH & Co. KG v Verbraucherzentrale NRW eV, that a website operator that features “Like" social-media plugin from Facebook likely qualifies as joint-controller with Facebook for its website visitors' personal data collection and transmission to Facebook.

The CJEU recalled that in order to qualify as “data controller", it is sufficient for a natural or legal person to exert influence over the processing of personal data for its own purposes even though such involvement only relates to one part of the processing. Different operators can thus be involved to different degrees, and their respective liabilities will then have to be assessed on a case-by-case basis.

The Advocate General stated in its opinion that an entity can qualify as controller only in relation to the operations of personal data processing for which it jointly determines the purposes and means, but not for any other parts of the overall chain of processing.

In this case, the CJEU stated that Fashion ID “appears to have made it possible for Facebook to obtain personal data of visitors to its website" as soon as that visitor accesses the website and irrespective of whether he or she is a Facebook user or whether he or she has even clicked the “Like" button. Hence, the CJEU concluded that in relation to this collection and transmission of the visitors' personal data to Facebook, both Facebook and Fashion ID qualify as joint-controllers because they determine together the means and origin of the processing operations. Indeed, by adding on this “Like" button to its website, Fashion ID optimises the exposure of its goods by increasing their visibility on Facebook.

All these conclusions are still formulated in a relatively hypothetical form by the CJEU since it is now up to the national referring Court to conduct the necessary investigations and render a final decision on the merits.

Related news

10.03.2022 EU law
De Dataverordening (“Data Act”)

Short Reads - De Europese Commissie heeft op 23 februari 2022 de Europese dataverordening (“Data Act”) voorgesteld, die het delen van data beoogt te bevorderen. Steeds meer gegevens worden door mensen en machines gegenereerd, bewaard en hergebruikt. Data en data-analyse kan een bijdrage leveren aan de efficiëntie van maatschappelijke processen, onderzoek en innovatie stimuleren en het concurrentievermogen van industrieën versterken. Veel data is echter niet vrij toegankelijk.  

Read more

11.05.2022 NL law
De afweging van grondrechten in het kader van corona

Articles - COVID-19 heeft de maatschappij voor dilemma’s geplaatst bij de afweging van volksgezondheid en bescherming van kwetsbaren tegenover vrijheden van het individu. In Tijdschrift voor Arbeidsrecht in Context schetsen Frederiek Fernhout en Judica Krikke de onderliggende rechten en vrijheden die vastgelegd zijn in het Europese grondrechtenkader, de AVG en nationale arbeidswetgeving en bespreken zij hoe deze tegen elkaar moeten worden afgewogen in de context van coronamaatregelen.

Read more

26.04.2022 EU law
Digital Law Up(to)date: Further clarification by the CJEU on the retention of traffic and location electronic communications data for the purpose of combating serious crime

Articles - On 5 April 2022, the Grand Chamber of the Court of Justice of the European Union first confirmed that EU law precludes national legislative measures which provide, as a preventative measure, for the general and indiscriminate retention of traffic and location data relating to electronic communications, for the purpose of combating serious crime.

Read more