Articles

Enable “likes” and bear joint-controllership

Enable “likes” and bear joint-controllership

Enable “likes” and bear joint-controllership

19.08.2019 EU law

The Court of Justice of the European Union recently ruled, in Case C-40/14 Fashion ID GmbH & Co. KG v Verbraucherzentrale NRW eV,  that a website operator that features “Like” social-media plugin from Facebook likely qualifies as joint-controller with Facebook for its website visitors’ personal data collection and transmission to Facebook.

The Court of Justice of the European Union recently ruled, in Case C-40/14 Fashion ID GmbH & Co. KG v Verbraucherzentrale NRW eV, that a website operator that features “Like" social-media plugin from Facebook likely qualifies as joint-controller with Facebook for its website visitors' personal data collection and transmission to Facebook.

The CJEU recalled that in order to qualify as “data controller", it is sufficient for a natural or legal person to exert influence over the processing of personal data for its own purposes even though such involvement only relates to one part of the processing. Different operators can thus be involved to different degrees, and their respective liabilities will then have to be assessed on a case-by-case basis.

The Advocate General stated in its opinion that an entity can qualify as controller only in relation to the operations of personal data processing for which it jointly determines the purposes and means, but not for any other parts of the overall chain of processing.

In this case, the CJEU stated that Fashion ID “appears to have made it possible for Facebook to obtain personal data of visitors to its website" as soon as that visitor accesses the website and irrespective of whether he or she is a Facebook user or whether he or she has even clicked the “Like" button. Hence, the CJEU concluded that in relation to this collection and transmission of the visitors' personal data to Facebook, both Facebook and Fashion ID qualify as joint-controllers because they determine together the means and origin of the processing operations. Indeed, by adding on this “Like" button to its website, Fashion ID optimises the exposure of its goods by increasing their visibility on Facebook.

All these conclusions are still formulated in a relatively hypothetical form by the CJEU since it is now up to the national referring Court to conduct the necessary investigations and render a final decision on the merits.

Related news

22.07.2021 NL law
Towards a European legal framework for the development and use of Artificial Intelligence

Short Reads - Back in 2014, Stephen Hawking said, “The development of full artificial intelligence could spell the end of the human race.” Although the use of artificial intelligence is nothing new and dates back to Alan Turing (the godfather of computational theory), prominent researchers – along with Stephen Hawking – have expressed their concerns about the unregulated use of AI systems and their impact on society as we know it.

Read more

19.07.2021 BE law
One year of Schrems II: a state of affairs for international data transfers

Articles - International data transfers have been the subject of intense debates ever since the Court of Justice issued its landmark judgement of Schrems I, on 6 October 2015. The intensity of the debate was further reinforced since the Schrems II decision one year ago, on 16 July 2020. The decision annulled the U.S. Privacy Shield and severely tightened the rules on the use of standard contractual clauses (“SCCs”).

Read more

18.05.2021 NL law
Kroniek: De bestuursrechtelijke aspecten van de AVG

Articles - Tom Barkhuysen, Steven Bastiaans en Fatma Çapkurt (Universiteit Leiden) schreven samen de eerste editie van de nieuwe jaarlijkse NTB kroniek: de bestuursrechtelijke aspecten van de AVG. Hierin bespreken zij onder meer de meest relevante (bestuursrechtelijke) jurisprudentie van het afgelopen jaar op het gebied van de AVG.

Read more

18.06.2021 NL law
FAQ: Wat houdt het Wetsvoorstel elektronische gegevensuitwisseling in de zorg (Wegiz) in en wat is de verhouding tot de AVG?

Short Reads - (Digitale) gegevensuitwisseling in de zorg is een actueel thema. Illustratief is een item bij EenVandaag van april 2021 waarin de analoge werkwijze bij gegevensuitwisseling in de zorg wordt aangekaart, maar ook dit artikel in het NRC van afgelopen maand waarin verslag werd gedaan van een datalek waardoor duizenden gevoelige patiëntgegevens op straat kwamen te liggen. 

Read more

04.05.2021 NL law
Participatie en privacyregels: hoe te combineren onder de Omgevingswet?

Short Reads - In het stelsel van de Omgevingswet (Ow) is een belangrijke rol bedacht voor participatie bij de totstandkoming van besluiten. Het beoogde resultaat: tijdig belangen, meningen en creativiteit op tafel krijgen en daarmee een groter draagvlak en kwalitatief betere besluitvorming bereiken. Door een grotere betrokkenheid van meer personen gaan overheden en initiatiefnemers ook meer persoonsgegevens verwerken. Dit brengt privacyrisico’s met zich mee. Wat regelt de Ow op het gebied van privacy, de verwerking van persoonsgegevens en datagebruik?

Read more