Short Reads

Stibbe Litigators participate in consultation draft bill to modernise the law of evidence

Stibbe Litigators participate in consultation draft bill to modernise

Stibbe Litigators participate in consultation draft bill to modernise the law of evidence

03.09.2018 NL law

Members of Stibbe’s Commercial Litigation practice group have participated in the public consultation of a draft bill to modernise and simplify the law of evidence in civil procedure.

An overview of the draft proposal was provided previously on this blog by Petra Vos and Daan Barbiers.

The main goal of the draft bill is to enhance truth seeking in civil procedure and to promote efficiency and effectiveness. To that effect, the draft bill proposes to extend the role of the court. When considering a claim or defence, the court is expected to introduce and investigate facts that were not brought forward by the parties, therefore extending the factual grounds in the proceedings. The draft bill also introduces a broad pre-trial information gathering duty for the parties, resembling pre-trial discovery in common law jurisdictions.

In their response to the draft bill, the members of the Commercial Litigation practice group have raised questions regarding these two elements. Establishing the truth and efficiency are both important aspects within civil procedure to arrive at a just and balanced outcome, but the draft bill overreaches itself. If the court uses its initiative to introduce new factual grounds in the proceedings, it inevitably participates in the debate between the parties. This undermines the independent role of the court. The proposed pre-trial information gathering obligation of the parties will increase costs and complicate the proceedings. This may impede access to justice.

The response is available here (in Dutch).

Team

Related news

16.09.2022 NL law
Webinar Verschoningsrecht

Articles - Tim de Greve gaat samen met Prof. Petra van Kampen in op actuele ontwikkelingen in het verschoningsrecht tijdens het webinar Verschoningsrecht van de Academie voor de Rechtspraktijk. Dit webinar is hier terug te kijken.

Read more

21.07.2022 NL law
Dutch Supreme Court decides against the pledgeability of non-transferable claims

Articles - Lawyers occasionally wonder how the law ended up as it is. We had that experience after the Dutch Supreme Court’s decision of 1 July 2022 (Rabobank/Ten Berge q.q.; ECLI:NL:HR:2022:984), regarding the possibility or impossibility of pledging a claim. The Supreme Court decided that claims that have been made non-transferable under property law in a contractual agreement between a creditor and a debtor, cannot be pledged either.

Read more

13.09.2022 NL law
Aard en uitleg van statuten

Short Reads - Al lange tijd is het een gemeenplaats in de rechtspraak en de literatuur dat statuten zo niet steeds, dan ten minste in beginsel naar objectieve maatstaven uitgelegd moeten worden. Ter ondersteuning van deze opvatting wordt aangevoerd dat de bijzondere aard van de statuten in beginsel tot een objectieve uitleg dwingt.

Read more

03.05.2022 NL law
Bijdrage Tijdschrift voor Insolventierecht

Articles - Gertjan Boekraad schreef voor het Tijdschrift voor Insolventierecht een annotatie bij een arrest van de Hoge Raad over de vraag hoe in het faillissement van een bedrijf om te gaan met de vordering van de overheid die een milieuovertreding van dat bedrijf moet herstellen.  

Read more