Short Reads

District Court of Amsterdam: The requirements imposed by law on assignment of claims for deprivation of voting rights on shares are largely the same as the requirements for claims for compulsory transfer of shares

Deprivation of voting rights on shares

District Court of Amsterdam: The requirements imposed by law on assignment of claims for deprivation of voting rights on shares are largely the same as the requirements for claims for compulsory transfer of shares

19.12.2016 NL law

That the corporate interests of a company are harmed through the actions of a pledgee holding the voting rights in respect of shares, does not in it itself increase support for a claim for deprivation of such voting rights as would be the case when claiming compulsory transfer of the actual shares - on the contrary, it appears.

Amsterdam District Court 4 May 2016 (ECLI:NL:RBAMS:2016:5819).

The relevant facts in this judgment are that the shares in the Dutch company were held by the claimant and a third party, who were both also the managing directors of the company. The company was party to a junior loan agreement. As security for the obligations under this junior loan agreement, the shareholders of the company  granted, among other things, a right of pledge over the shares in the company in favour of a well-known financial institution. Following an event of default which is continuing, under the junior loan agreement, the voting rights on the shares were transferred to the financial institution.

After several years, the financial institution was requested by the claimant and its co-director to cooperate in convening a formal shareholders' meeting on a number of matters, including the dismissal of the claimant and its co-director as directors of the company and the subsequent appointment of new directors. The financial institution refused,  stating it was not in the corporate interests of the company to replace the directors and that the voting rights did not permit it to convene a formal shareholders' meeting. The claimant asked the court to rule that the decision reached by the financial institution was not in the company’s best interests and that it was no longer possible to expect the financial institution to reasonably exercise its voting rights. The claimant requested the financial institution be deprived of its voting rights and that such voting rights be transferred back to the company's shareholders.

The court ruled that the requirements the law imposes on assignment of a claim for deprivation of voting rights are not materially different to the requirements for a claim for compulsory transfer of shares. The standard of conduct for either claim is composed of the following three elements: (i) it must concern conduct of the shareholder or pledgee, (ii) which harms the corporate interest of the company in such a way that (iii) exercising the voting rights on the shares by either the shareholder or pledgee can no longer be reasonably expected to continue. The second element in this standard of conduct is difficult to fulfil under both types of claim, as the pledgee has a legitimate (financial and practical) interest vested in the use of the voting rights. The court acknowledged that this interest may not always coincide with the interests of the company, but held that the corporate interest must sometimes give way to the vested  interests of the pledgee in order to prevent the erosion of a share pledge as a form of security in financial transactions. In light of this judgment, caution should be exercised when assessing whether the conduct of a pledgee damages the company's corporate interests in such a way that its voting rights should be transferred back to the shareholders.

Team

Related news

15.11.2019 NL law
Het kerstmenu van de AFM: vijf gangen - Column Fondsnieuws

Short Reads - Vliegen de pepernoten, adventskalenders en kerstkransjes u alweer om de oren?  Nee, het aanmeten van een gezonde levensstijl wordt u aan het einde van het jaar niet makkelijk gemaakt. Gelukkig helpt het Voedingscentrum ons daar een handje bij; en wel met de 'Schijf van Vijf'. De AFM introduceerde vorig jaar iets vergelijkbaars voor de financiële sector.

Read more

07.11.2019 NL law
Banking & Finance 2019 Second Edition – The Netherlands and Luxembourg chapter

Articles - Maarten de Bruin, Rein van Helden, Rogier Raas and Robert Steeg have all contributed to the Chambers and Partners Banking & Finance 2019 Second Edition, providing the Netherlands chapter. The Luxembourg chapter was written by Gérald Origer, Jean-Marc Delcour, Steven Paridaens and Nicolas Pradel.

Read more

13.11.2019 NL law
A new Act on the Supervision of Trust Offices

Articles - Roderik Vrolijk and Soeradj Ramsanjhal published an article in the Dutch Financial Law Review as a follow-up on their article two years ago in the same journal. The authors specifically shed light on the customer due diligence and open norms of the new Act on the Supervision of Trust Offices 2018, that entered into force on 1 January 2019. 

Read more

31.10.2019 NL law
EBA Publishes Follow-Up Report on 2018 FinTech Roadmap

Short Reads - Building on its 2018 FinTech Roadmap, the EBA has issued a report focused on potential impediments to the cross-border provision of banking and payment services. In the 29 October 2019 report, the EBA identifies three regulatory areas in which the further integration of European banking and payment services markets can be improved.  The three areas the EBA addresses are authorisation and licensing, conduct of business and consumer protection requirements, and anti-money laundering ("AML") and countering the financing of terrorism ("CFT").

Read more

08.11.2019 BE law
Interview with Wouter Ghijsels on Next Gen lawyers

Articles - Stibbe’s managing partner Wouter Ghijsels shares his insights on the next generation of lawyers and the future of the legal profession at the occasion of the Leaders Meeting Paris where Belgian business leaders, politicians and inspiring people from the cultural and academic world will discuss this year's central theme "The Next Gen".

Read more

Our website uses functional cookies for the functioning of the website and analytic cookies that enable us to generate aggregated visitor data. We also use other cookies, such as third party tracking cookies - please indicate whether you agree to the use of these other cookies:

Privacy – en cookieverklaring